This post is written for two kinds of employers. The first is starting a 401(k) plan for the first time and isn't sure what a provider actually does. The second already has a plan and is thinking about replacing its current provider. The steps are the same for both. Learn the services every 401(k) needs, compare which of those services each provider covers, find out which fiduciary roles each provider will accept, understand the fees, and ask every provider the same questions.
Why This Matters
Picture a plan where everything looks in order. Employees are enrolled, contributions show up in their accounts each payday, and the provider's website is easy to use. Then a participant asks why the plan's fees are what they are, or a Department of Labor investigator asks for the documents showing how the provider was selected. The employer opens the plan file and finds a sales brochure and a signed contract. Nothing in the file shows which other providers were considered, what questions were asked, or why this provider was picked.
Under federal law, choosing a plan's service providers is a fiduciary decision. The person making it has to act prudently and only in the interest of the plan's participants. Prudence is judged by the process behind a decision, so the record of how a provider was chosen matters as much as the choice itself.
The worksheet below helps you build that record as you go. It lists the services to check, the questions to send every provider, and a page to record your final decision
What Should You Look for in a 401(k) Provider?
Every 401(k) plan needs the same core services, no matter who provides them:
- Recordkeeping: tracking each employee's account balance, contributions, investment choices and loans.
- Administration: running the annual nondiscrimination tests, preparing the Form 5500 the plan files each year, and sending required notices to employees.
- Investment oversight: choosing the funds employees can pick from and monitoring those funds over time.
- A trustee or custodian: holding the plan's money. Federal law generally requires a plan's assets to be held in trust.
- Employee education: helping employees understand how to enroll, how much to save, and how to choose investments.
Some providers handle all of these services under one contract. This is called a bundled provider. Other providers handle one or two services and work alongside separate firms for the rest, which is called an unbundled arrangement. For example, one firm might keep the account records, a second firm might handle testing and government filings, and an investment advisor might choose the funds.
Neither setup is required. A bundled provider means one contract and one point of contact. An unbundled arrangement lets the employer choose each firm separately, but the employer then has to oversee each firm separately.
Next, confirm that each provider supports the plan features you want:
- Roth contributions, which employees make after tax and can later withdraw tax-free if they meet the rules.
- A safe harbor design, which lets a plan skip certain nondiscrimination tests in exchange for required employer contributions.
- Automatic enrollment. A newly established 401(k) plan generally has to enroll eligible employees automatically. Businesses that have existed for less than three years are exempt. So are businesses that have never normally employed more than 10 employees, until one year after the end of the tax year in which they first do.
- Loans and hardship withdrawals, if you want employees to have access to them.
Finally, ask how the provider connects to your payroll system. Employee contributions become plan money as soon as they can reasonably be separated from the company's own money, so they need to reach the plan by then. When your payroll system sends contribution data to the provider automatically, that can mean fewer manual uploads and less chance of a missed or late deposit.
Should Your 401(k) Provider Handle Plan Administration?
Plan administration is the ongoing work of running a plan day to day. It includes:
- tracking which employees are eligible to join the plan and when
- approving loans and distributions
- running the annual nondiscrimination tests
- preparing and filing the Form 5500
- sending required notices, such as participant fee disclosures and the summary annual report
Unless the plan document names someone else, the employer is the plan administrator under federal law. That means the employer is responsible for this work even when a provider performs some of it.
Providers take on administration in one of two ways. A third-party administrator, or TPA, performs the tasks within rules the employer sets. A TPA that only does that work isn't a fiduciary for it, so the employer stays the plan administrator and reviews the TPA's work. A 3(16) administrator is named in the plan documents and accepts responsibility in writing for the administrative duties it takes on.
An employer with no one on staff who knows retirement plan rules can have a provider formally take on the plan administrator role instead of reviewing a TPA's work itself. The employer still has to monitor the provider it chose.
What Fiduciary Responsibilities Can a 401(k) Provider Take On?
A fiduciary is anyone who has discretionary authority over a plan's management, its administration or its money, or who gives the plan investment advice for a fee. Every fiduciary has to act prudently and only in the participants' interest. A provider can take on four fiduciary roles:
- 3(21) investment adviser: recommends funds and monitors them, and is a fiduciary for the advice it gives. The employer makes the final investment decisions and stays responsible for them.
- 3(38) investment manager: chooses, monitors and replaces the funds itself and accepts responsibility for those decisions. A 3(38) manager has to be a registered investment adviser, a bank or an insurance company, and has to acknowledge in writing that it's a fiduciary.
- 3(16) plan administrator: takes on the administrative duties described above.
- Trustee: holds the plan's assets. A directed trustee follows the employer's instructions. A discretionary trustee makes decisions about plan assets within the authority the plan gives it.
A provider can describe itself as "full-service" and still accept none of these roles. The contract and the provider's fee disclosure show which roles it actually accepts. Before the contract is signed, a covered provider has to state in writing whether it will serve as a fiduciary to the plan. Ask each provider to name, in the contract, every fiduciary role it accepts.
Whichever roles a provider accepts, two duties stay with the employer: choosing the provider prudently and reviewing its work after the contract is signed. For the investment roles, the choice usually comes down to sharing investment decisions with an adviser or handing them to a manager.
How Much Does a 401(k) Provider Cost?
A 401(k) plan has four main types of fees:
- Recordkeeping and administration fees: the cost of keeping the accounts and running the plan.
- Advisory fees: what an investment adviser or investment manager charges.
- Investment expenses: each fund's expense ratio, which is taken out of the fund's returns and paid by the participants who hold it. Some funds pass part of this expense to the recordkeeper, which is called revenue sharing.
- One-time fees: setup fees for a new plan, conversion fees when moving from another provider, and termination fees when leaving a provider.
Providers charge these fees in three ways: a flat dollar amount each year, a set amount per participant, or a percentage of plan assets. A percentage-of-assets fee grows as the plan grows, even if the work the provider does stays the same.
The employer can pay some fees directly from the business. The plan can also pay reasonable administrative expenses from plan assets, which reduces participants' account balances. Ask each provider which fees the employer pays and which fees come out of the plan.
Before the contract is signed, a covered provider that expects to receive $1,000 or more has to give the plan fiduciary who signs the contract a written disclosure describing its services, its compensation and its fiduciary status. Lay these disclosures side by side. The total of all fees for the services you need is the number to compare, not any single fee.
What Questions Should You Ask a 401(k) Provider?
These questions cover the services, roles and fees described above:
- Which of the core services do you provide yourself, and which do you rely on another firm for?
- Which fiduciary roles will you accept, and where in the contract are they named?
- What are all of your fees, how is each one charged, and who pays it?
- How long does the contract run, and what fees apply if the employer leaves?
- How does your system connect to our payroll, and who sends the contribution data each pay period?
- What will employees see, including the website, statements and the phone number they call with questions?
- What does the employer have to do each year, and what do you do?
- Can we speak with current clients whose plans are a similar size to ours?
- What are your information security policies, and what were the results of your most recent independent security audit?
- Have you had a security breach, and do you carry insurance that covers losses from cybersecurity incidents?
How you ask the questions matters as much as the questions. Start with one written description of the plan: the number of employees, whether this is a new plan or a move from a current provider, the plan features you want, your payroll system, and the services you want a provider to handle. Send that same description and the same questions to every provider you're considering, and ask each provider for written answers and a formal bid. When every provider answers the same questions about the same plan, the answers can be compared line by line.
What Goes in the Selection Record
The answers are only half of what you're collecting. Together with a few other documents, they become the selection record: the file that shows how the employer reached its decision. A complete selection record holds:
- the written plan description sent to every provider
- the list of providers contacted and the date each one was contacted
- each provider's written answers and formal bid
- each provider's fee disclosure
- a short decision note naming the provider chosen, the reasons it was chosen over the others, who approved the choice, and the date
Keep the selection record with the plan's other records. If the choice is ever questioned, the file shows which providers were compared, what each one said, and why the employer chose the one it did. It's the same reason a plan should keep a written record of the decisions its committee makes.
Before You Sign With a Provider
Before signing, check the contract against the provider's written answers. The contract should list the services the provider promised, name each fiduciary role it accepts, and show fees that match its fee disclosure. If the provider described cybersecurity practices, the contract should require it to keep following them.
After the contract is signed, the employer's work shifts to monitoring. That means reviewing the provider's fees, service and investment results on a regular schedule, and keeping notes from each review in the same file as the selection record.
The 401(k) Provider Selection Worksheet walks through each step in this post and gives you a page to record your final decision. If you'd like help comparing the providers on your list, call First Hill Trust at (206) 625-1800 or schedule a call here.
Important Disclosures
First Hill Trust Company is a Washington State-chartered trust company. Investment advisory services are provided by BAC Capital Advisors, an SEC-registered investment adviser and a wholly owned subsidiary of First Hill Trust Company. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This article is educational. Neither First Hill Trust Company nor BAC Capital Advisors is acting as ERISA counsel or tax counsel to any plan or plan sponsor, and nothing here replaces advice from qualified counsel about your own plan.
Accuracy and currency. Statutory provisions and regulatory descriptions in this article were checked against the cited primary sources as of the date of publication, but First Hill Trust Company and BAC Capital Advisors make no representation or warranty as to the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the information, and accept no liability for actions taken in reliance on it. Regulations and guidance change. Confirm current requirements with qualified counsel.
Educational purpose only. Provided by First Hill Trust Company for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not legal, tax, accounting, investment, or fiduciary advice, does not constitute a recommendation regarding any plan, investment, strategy, or course of action, and does not consider any recipient’s specific circumstances. Consult your own qualified advisors before acting.
No offer, agreement, or commitment. Nothing in this material constitutes an offer, solicitation, agreement, or commitment to provide any particular service or to assume any particular responsibility. Descriptions of what a trustee, administrator, adviser, committee, employer, or other party “may” or “can” do are illustrative of how such arrangements commonly work and do not describe the terms of any specific engagement. The actual services provided, the allocation of responsibilities, the scope of any delegation, and the duties of any party are governed solely by the applicable plan documents, trust agreement, advisory agreement, and written service agreements. In the event of any inconsistency, those documents control.
Services and regulatory status. First Hill Trust Company and its affiliates offer retirement plan services, recordkeeping and administrative services, trust and fiduciary services, investment advisory services, and group benefits services, in each case subject to applicable regulatory requirements and the terms of the relevant agreements. Not all services are offered to all clients, in all states, or in all circumstances. Investment advisory services are offered through an affiliated investment adviser; a copy of its Form ADV Part 2A is available upon request. Insurance and group benefits products are offered through appropriately licensed entities. The availability and scope of any service depend on eligibility and the applicable agreements.
Fiduciary status under ERISA. Fiduciary status under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (“ERISA”), is determined based on the functions performed and the authority exercised, not on titles or labels. Whether any particular party is acting as a fiduciary, and the scope of any related duties or potential liability, depends on the facts and circumstances specific to the plan and the relationship. Engaging a trustee, adviser, or other service provider does not eliminate a plan sponsor’s or committee’s own fiduciary responsibilities, including the duties to prudently select and monitor any party to whom responsibilities are delegated.
Affiliated entities and conflicts of interest. First Hill Trust Company is affiliated with other entities, including an affiliated investment adviser and entities providing administrative, trust, or other services. These relationships may create conflicts of interest, including where an affiliate is engaged or compensated in connection with a plan. Such conflicts and compensation are described in the applicable service agreements and the affiliated adviser’s Form ADV Part 2A; fiduciaries should consider them when evaluating any engagement.
Statutory and regulatory references. References to ERISA, the Internal Revenue Code, and related statutory or regulatory provisions are general summaries only. They are not a substitute for review of the actual statutory text, regulations, or guidance from the Department of Labor, Internal Revenue Service, or other relevant authorities, and they do not address how those provisions may apply to any particular plan, sponsor, fiduciary, or individual. Laws, regulations, and guidance are subject to change and to interpretation by the relevant agencies and courts. Examples, categories, and situations described are simplified for illustration and may not reflect the requirements or circumstances of any particular plan or person.
No guarantee of results; investment risk. References to governance, fiduciary practices, risk reduction, or outcomes describe common industry approaches and potential benefits, not promises or guarantees of any result, of compliance, or of protection from liability, loss, or claims. All investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal; diversification does not ensure a profit or protect against loss. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
For more information, contact First Hill Trust Company at (206) 625-1800.